in

Smoker Tubes vs. Smoker Boxes: The Ultimate Comparison

Learn all the differences between smoker boxes and pellet smoker tubes, how to use these great smoking devices to smoke great BBQ on ANY grill, and which to use in various situations.

Let’s go!

 

a smoker box

What are Smoker Boxes and Smoker Tubes Used For?

Smoker boxes and smoker tubes, sometimes called “pellet tube smokers” are two different devices used to hold wood chips and wood pellets respectively primarily for smoking on a gas grill.

Yes, you CAN smoke great food on ANY gas grill using these devices.

Simply set the grill up for indirect cooking and place either the box or tube over the lit burners on the hot side and your meat on the cool side and smoke away!

You can read more in-depth on how to set up a gas grill for smoking here.

Ok, so if they both do the same thing, what’s the difference between the two?

Well they have some distinct differences that we will get into next.

Basically a smoker TUBE is designed to hold wood pellets, like the ones used in a pellet grill uch as a Traeger or a Camp Chef.

A smoker BOX is designed to hold wood chips, not pellets.

Let’s look at each one individually and why you might pick to use one over the other.

 

Smoker Tubes

Why Use a Pellet Tube Smoker? 

Smoker tubes, or, pellet tube smokers are a handy accessory to have

LIZZQ Premium Pellet Smoker Tube 12 inches - 5 Hours of Billowing Smoke - for Any Grill or Smoker, Hot or Cold Smoking - An Easy and Safe Way to Provide Smoking - Free eBook Grilling Ideas and Recipes

Check out this Smoker Tube on Amazon

They allow you to take advantage of the benefits of hardwood pellets for smoking without even owning a pellet grill

Wood Pellets are much denser and more compressed than wood chips, which you would use in a smoker box.

Because of this, they burn much slower and, pound for pound, produce a lot more smoke during a long cook.

 

Benefits of a Pellet Tube Smoker

To start with, you can actually use a pellet tube smoker to cold smoke foods like jerky and cheese.

One particular challenge when it comes to cold smoking is often being able to expose your food to the smoke without actually heating it up.

Pellet Smoker Tube, 12

This can cause a whole range of issues, like melted cheese making a big mess all over your grill.

If you have a pellet tube smoker, you have a portable device that you can set far away from the cold food, and you can even keep some ice and water trays in between your food and the tube. 

Having a pellet tube smoker almost completely eliminates the need to go buy a high priced smoker or pellet grill, allowing you to create not only traditional BBQ, but a variety of smokey food like prime rib, ham, bratwurst, and even a thanksgiving turkey right on your gas grill using indirect heat.

 

How Does It Work?

It’s actually pretty easy to use a pellet tube smoker, and there are a few different ways you can use it to create aromatic wood smoke.

First, make sure to fill up the pellet tube using wood pellets, not chips. 

The pellet tube allows a LOT more oxygen inside than a smoker box, which the pellets need in order to smolder due to how compressed they are.

If you try to put wood chips in a smoker tube they will likely just ignite, causing an unwanted fire in your gas grill. 

No good.

For wood chips, always use a smoker box like this one, which is designed to restrict oxygen, causing the chips to smolder and smoke:

Hot Smoking with a Pellet Tube Smoker

Once you’ve filled up the tube, you have the option to place it on top of a burner if you are hot smoking a typical BBQ food

Place the tube either on the grill grates above the burner, or down against the heat diffusers that cover the propane gas flames.

It is NOT recommended that you place the tube smoker DIRECTLY against the flame outlets of the burner.

 

Cold Smoking with a Pellet Tube Smoker

If you are Cold Smoking food like gouda cheese, keep the burners off and light up the far end of the pellet filled tube directly with a lighter.

Note that you can’t use a standard cigarette lighter – it has to be a butane torch.

Heat one end of the pellets in the tube until they are thoroughly ignited and smoking even after removing the butane flame.  Then place the smoking tube at one side of the grill and your food at the other.

If lighting directly with a torch, you should let the flame burn for around 7 to 8 minutes first before it begins to smolder for the best results.

 

 

Things to Consider Before Purchasing a Pellet Tube Smoker

There are a plethora of different pellet tube smokers on the market, and first glance they all tend to look very similar.

That’s why we put together a list of our FIVE favorite pellet smoker tubes HERE to help you narrow down your choice.

 

Smoker Boxes

Ok, now ets take a look at the counterpart to the smoker tube, the smoker box.

What is a Smoker Box?

A smoker box, or smoking box, is essentially a small rectangular box with slots cut in the top. The box is typically made out of stainless steel or cast iron and the top part flips back or comes completely off.

Smoker Box for Wood Chips - Use a Gas or Charcoal BBQ Grill and Still Get That Delicious Smoky Barbecue Flavored Grilled Meat - Hinged Lid for Easy Access (polished finish stainless steel)

Check out this Smoker Box on Amazon

You’ll put your favorite kind of wood chips in this box and then close it before putting it in your grill.

Just like you shouldn’t put wood chips in a smoker tube, don’t put pellets in your smoker box.

Nothing will likely happen because they wont get enough oxygen to ignite and smolder.

 

How Does a Smoker Box Work?

The idea is pretty simple. You fill the small box with wood chips to heat up on the grill and add smoke flavor to whatever you are cooking.

As the grill heats up the box, the wood starts to smoke.  The small slits in the box limit the amount of oxygen that reaches the wood, allowing it to smolder and smoke rather than ignite and catch fire.

Using a wood chip smoker box is kind of like adding an additional layer of seasoning.

How much wood you put in the box and how many times you refill it during the cook will determine how much smoky flavor you get in the meat you’re cooking.

Char-Broil Cast Iron Smoker Box

Check out this Cast Iron Smoker Box on Amazon

A smoker box gives you the ability to apply smoke to food on a conventional grill where you can’t  easily limit the airflow.  (Notice the large open vent on the back of your typical propane gas grill).

The smoker box keeps the wood contained and allows it to heat up to the 500 degree range where smoke begins to occur.

Contrary to popular advice:

YOU DO NOT NEED TO SOAK THE WOOD CHIPS prior to adding them to your smoker box.

It will not hurt to do it, but it is an unnecessary step and it will just end up taking longer for the wood to smoke as you wait for all that water to evaporate.

The smoke is created by the lack of oxygen in the smoker box, not by soaking the wood chips in water.

If you place the smoker box down in the coals or near the burners under the meat you are cooking, the smoke will gently rise out of the box and begin the flavor your food above it.

 

How to Use a Smoker Box on a Gas Grill

a weber gas grill

First, preheat your grill.

Turn all the burners on the highest setting and let it get nice and hot.  Make sure to always clean your grates with a good grill brush after it preheats.

While you’re waiting, fill up your smoker box.

Now it’s time to throw that smoker box in there. The ideal placement is resting on the burners but below the grill.  Again, depending on the size and style of your grill you may need to play with this setup.

If you have a grill with flame deflector bars, we like this design of smoker box for positioning the box securely under the grill grate.

Charcoal Companion Stainless Steel V-Shape Smoker Box For Gas Grill Wood Chips (Long) - CC4066

Check out this V-Shaped Smoker Box on Amazon

DO NOT turn the gas burner the smoker box is sitting on up to HIGH.

Even with limited oxygen inside the box the chips may still ignite at these high direct temperatures.

If you need to cook your food at a very high direct temperature, use the burners next to the smoker box burner to actually cook the food.

Its OK to put the smoker box on the grill grates next to the meat, you just may lose a lot of smoke out the rear air vent before it ever reaches the meat, so below the grate is a better option.

 

Smoking Times of Smoker Tubes vs. Smoker Boxes

The main difference between the two devices is going to be how long each one produces smoke.

 

Pellet Smoker Tubes

Hands down the winner for length of smoking time will always be the Pellet Smoker TUBE.

Pellet Smoker Tube -12

Check out this Extra Long Pellet Tube on Amazon

As we mentioned, pellets are made from compressed sawdust and therefore smolder and burn very slowly.

A full pellet tube can provide even smoke for up to 4-5 hours before needing to be refilled.

For most large cuts of meat, this is all the amount of time they can absorb smoke anyways, so you likely only ever have to fill up the pellet tube once per cook.

 

Smoker Boxes

Wood Chips on the other hand are made from just, well, wood.

Small bits and shavings of it usually about an inch long to be exact.

Smoker Box for BBQ Grill Wood Chips - 25% THICKER STAINLESS STEEL WON'T WARP - Charcoal & Gas Barbecue Meat Smoking with Hinged Lid - Best Grilling Accessories & Utensils Gift for Dad by Cave Tools

These will smolder and smoke much quicker than the pellets, with a full smoker box usually only lasting about 20-30 minutes at best.

This is great if you are just quick-smoking some lobster tails, or a couple of steaks or chicken thighs.

But if you are trying to smoke a large pork butt or beef brisket, you are going to find yourself dumping and refilling the smoker box many times during the cook in order to keep the smoke going.

 

Costs of Using Smoker Tubes vs. Smoker Boxes

While the price of a smoker tube and a smoker box are roughly the same (with the smoker box being possibly a little cheaper in some instances), the bigger difference is in the price of using wood pellets vs. chips.

Many people balk at the price of wood pellets, especially name brand pellets like those put out by big companies in the space like Traeger.

They compare the prices by volume to wood chips and quickly declare the pellets a “rip-off” and buy the wood chips instead.

However…

Knowing what we know about how pellets burn slower than wood chips, this is not really a fair comparison.

While you may pay more by volume for pellets than chips, if you compare them pound for pound and based on how much smoking time you get out of the pellets, the cost differences are are not as great.

In many cases, especially if you do a lot of long low and slow smoking, you may actually come out ahead using the wood pellets due to their longer burn time.

You can also find less expensive off brands of wood pellets other than ones put out by the bug pellet grill manufacturers.

For instance, we are big fans of the Bear Mountain Brand, and you will generally find brands like these to be significantly less expensive than say the Traeger brand pellets.

 

Smoker Tubes vs. Smoker Boxes: The Verdict

So in the end, your choice really comes down to how much smoking you do and for how long you want to smoke the foods you are making on your gas grill.

If you just want to add a little wood smoke here and there to your steaks and chops, then a smoker box will work just fine for you.

If, on the other hand, you want to do some longer low and slow cooks on your gas grill like ribs, pork butt, and beef brisket, then a pellet tube smoker is probably the better investment to make.

 

Moving on to Full Size Smokers and Pellet Grills

There is absolutely nothing wrong with using smoker tubes and soker boxes on the gas grill you already own.

For many of us self proclaimed BBQ aficionados, this is exactly how we too started down the path to smoked meat enlightenment.

However, if you are ready to take your BBQ game to the next level, and really have some fun, there are a bunch of great, affordable, easy to use smokers on the market today that are great for beginners.

We put together a list of our FAVORITE Smokers for Beginners HERE so go ahead and check it out.

Masterbuilt MB20074719 Bluetooth Digital Electric Smoker, 40 inch, Stainless Steel

Check out the Masterbuilt Electric Smoker on Amazon

Also, if you like how the pellet tube smokers work and want to learn more about using a full size pellet grill, we’ve got you covered too.

Check out this in-depth tutorial on how a pellet grill works, as well as our list of our FAVORITE pellet grills on the market priced under $500.

PIT BOSS PB440D2 Wood Pellet Grill, Mahogany

Check out this Pit Boss Pellet Smoker on Amazon

 

Thank for checking us out and good luck smoking!

 

 

sliced smoked prime rib

How to Smoke a Prime Rib on a Traeger Pellet Grill

smoked tilapia on a traeger smoker pellet grill

How to Make Smoked Tilapia